LANSING, MI (WKZO AM/FM) – The Michigan Supreme Court is set to reexamine the life without parole sentences of three men who have spent two decades in prison, convicted of murder at ages 18, 19 and 20.
The justices will consider several factors, including the age and immaturity of the individuals, their family and home environment and the circumstances of the crimes. In 2022, the Court ruled mandatory no-parole sentences for 18-year-olds convicted of murder violated the state constitution’s prohibition on “cruel or unusual” punishment. It will now decide whether to extend the ruling to 19- and 20-year-olds.
Quinn Yeargain, associate professor of law at Michigan State University, supports the court’s decision to review the cases.
“There’s a good amount of literature out there suggesting that people who are in their late teens and even going into their early twenties, their brains are not fully developed,” Yeargain pointed out. “That’s sort of the basis of this constitutional challenge.”
Critics of reducing life sentences for young offenders argued it is contradictory to claim individuals old enough to vote, marry and obtain abortions without parental consent should not be held fully accountable for their serious crimes.
The high court will also look at how the offenders dealt with police and prosecutors and whether they can be rehabilitated and reintegrated into society. Yeargain emphasized it is not about giving someone a “get out of jail free card.” He said Michigan’s parole board, which operates within the Department of Corrections, is known for being overly cautious in ensuring individuals seeking parole have genuinely undergone rehabilitation.
“We’re talking about people who are still going to be serving very long prison terms, and it’s just a statement that maybe they’ll be eligible for parole at a certain point,” Yeargain emphasized. “If they’re able to make a showing that they have changed, they have demonstrated remorse — then they may be entitled to release at that point.”
In Michigan, no-parole life sentences for those 18 or younger are no longer automatic. Judges review their background and potential for rehabilitation, while prosecutors must justify the sentence. The court plans to review the cases in the fall.
Comments